Subscribe to my updates via email by entering your email address below:


more hey lady!

currently reading

  • Succubus Blues (Georgina Kincaid, Book 1)

  • Birds of Paradise: A Novel

We will always miss you:

Love this shirt:

Website development by:

Temptation Designs



recent posts

did you say that outloud?

cringe worthy


Review – Sounds Like Crazy by Shana Mahaffey

Sounds Like Crazy
by Shana Mahaffey
400 pages
Published October 6, 2009

You know how, sometimes you end up reading a book that you wouldn’t normally have read, but it turned out to be a total gem? Yeah, that’s what happened for me with Sounds Like Crazy.

Author Shana Mahaffey approached me back in September 2009 asking if I’d read and review her book, Sounds Like Crazy. I was hesitant because, well, frankly, the book didn’t intrigue me. But she knew Michelle Gagnon, who I’ve made no bones about loving, AND she seemed to have read my review policy, and saw I wasn’t into chick lit. Two points for Shana! I accepted the book and I finally got around to reading it, and hoo boy no one told me I was in for such a treat!

Stick with me on this, because the plot’s a little different: Holly Miller has dissociative identity disorder (aka multiple personality disorder), so she’s got these people in her head that are constantly there. (I know! You’re mind has already gone to Sybil!) These other personalities are: Betty Jane, the leader of the pack, Ruffles, the morbidly obese woman who wears a lot of purple and eats Ruffles chips, Sarge, the one who can be counted on to keep order, The Boy, a young boy who sometimes speaks but never shows his face, and The Silent One. These all call themselves The Committee, and together they help Holly lead a normal life. By that I mean Betty Jane helps her get better tips (Betty Jane is waaaayyy more confident and has a really cool southern drawl) at the diner Holly works at. While Holly technically can function in society, she’s not doing the best job, as she can’t always control Betty Jane’s behavior when Betty Jane takes over.

Holly serendipitously waits on a customer whose boss has created an animated show and was in the process of looking for voice over artists. Betty Jane’s voice is perfect, and Holly lands the job. Unfortunately for Holly, Betty Jane makes demands of Holly (shopping sprees, drivers to pick them up and take them to work, etc)Β in order to continue doing the voice overs. Holly’s thin facade begins to crumble.

In the meantime, Holly’s been in therapy trying to deal with her DID, and she’s simultaneously dating Peter, a guy that’s totally wrong for her.

I was cautiously optimistic about this book after the first few pages. Whatever I thought it might be, it wasn’t. It was better. I ride the bus to work, and I rarely get so engrossed in a book that I forget to check where we are in the route and/or whether we’ll be on time to my connecting bus. This isn’t because books haven’t been that awesome, but I just don’t want to miss my stop or my next bus! While reading Sounds Like Crazy, I got so caught up in it on the bus that when the bus stopped at the transit mall, which is where I catch my connecting bus, I looked up, startled, and it took me a few seconds before I realized where we were. I’d gotten that engrossed in the book.

I was about halfway through Sounds Like Crazy when I had my real life book club meeting. I brought my book because…well, you never know when you’ll find a few seconds to read and I take the book I’m currently reading with me EVERYWHERE, and I mentioned it to my book club because they’re always pooh-poohing my dark and heavy suggestions, and I was surprised with how excited I was about this book! The greatness just snuck up on me and when I mentioned it, my excitement just bubbled out. I was so passionate about Sounds Like Crazy that we ended up making it our June selection.

One thing I love about Sounds Like Crazy is that you’ve essentially got three main characters: Holly, Betty Jane, and Ruffles. And while I didn’t laugh out loud, I was really invested in how these other personalities affected Holly, both good and bad. Betty Jane really has no regard for Holly, so she’s always doing these self-destructive things (and by that I mean, things that get Holly fired from her job because Betty Jane is a narcissistic diva, but the other personalities can’t stand up to Betty Jane, so while you’re rooting for Holly to succeed (and that usually involves Betty Jane), you’re also cringing because you know this isn’t sustainable.

I know I haven’t told you much about Shana’s writing style or any literary blah blah blah, but I hope that I’ve SHOWED you just how much I liked it as opposed to just telling you, It’s grrreat! And no, I don’t think everyone will like it. I think part of the reason I liked it was because some of the themes resonated with me. I’ve been in therapy before, so the feelings that Holly felt while in therapy rang true. I love that Shana uses these other personalities to explore those people we hold closest to our hearts. I can’t wait to discuss this in my book club!

Rating: 90 out of 100

Shana Mahaffey’s website:

Book source: I received this book from the author.

| Tags: 12 comments »

12 Responses to “Review – Sounds Like Crazy by Shana Mahaffey”

  1. Coffee and a Book Chick

    Ooh, this does sound like quite a treat to read! And I’m intrigued by anything that makes us miss our stops when we’re reading away!


  2. Topher ()

    Haha, what a fantastic review. Funny how mentioning your review policy earned so many points. I am not at all surprised by that!

    Also, I’ll miss the days when not getting off at the right stop is no longer correlated to how engrossed I am in a book. One time I missed my stop and decided to just ride four five more just to get to a good break point, and then I switched to an audio on the way uptown. Oh, lordy.


  3. zibilee

    I wasn’t as crazy as you were about this book, but it did have some excellent components and was a very interesting read. I do have to admit, that while I didn’t totally love it, I was glued to the page. Great review, Trish! I am so glad this one worked so well for you!!


  4. bermudaonion (Kathy)

    The chaos between the personalities does sound like it would make for some fun reading!


  5. Lenore ()

    Wow – that sounds like me, taking almost a year to get to my review books (or more…)


  6. Tiina ()

    Sound intriguing! I’ll have to keep this book in mind.
    And your enthusiasm really shines through your review! πŸ™‚



  7. Amy ()

    I won a copy of this book awhile ago and you really have me thinking I need to pick it up soon! Great review!


  8. Meg Waite Clayton ()

    Hmmmm … May have to look for this one now. Why does the fall always bring such a glut of wonderful books?


  9. Veens

    I am definitely going to order this one for me nxt time. Thank you, I love your enthusiasm and it made me smile!


  10. jennygirl

    I too have almost missed my subway stop because of a good book. I really should be more aware of my surroundings.

    I love it when a book totally surprises you. Something you wouldn’t normally read, grabs and takes you for a spin. I will keep this book in mind. Thanks for the brilliant review.


  11. melanie ()

    I love being surprised by books! Love this review – perfect story to get me to read it. πŸ™‚


  12. Jennifer

    This sounds like a treasure to read. I love a story that just engrosses you so much that the rest of the world doesn’t seem to matter – you just want to keep reading. And this sounds like it is that kind of book. I’m definitely adding it to my TBR list. Thanks for your wonderful review!


Leave a Reply

Back to top